The only metaphorical support I can give to this claim is that loving Buffy Summers is like leaving the best movie you've ever seen or hearing the most beautiful song you've ever heard. When the show was on it was fantastic - and sure you can watch the DVDs, read the blogs, attend the sing-a-longs. But Buffy isn't a pop-culture phenomenon anymore. She has her place in history as a pop-culture icon to be sure. But there are no longer Entertainment Weekly articles offering commentary on her plot arcs. Her cut-out has disappeared from the glassy store front of FYE and can be found only through internet searches.
People aren't updating their Buffy/Angel fanfics anymore.
There's a certain nostalgic undertaking that comes with being a present day Buffy fan. When you turn on the T.V. and are inundated with the mindless and casual copulation of "college students" on Gossip Girl, as a Buffy fan, you can't help but feel cheated. Don't even get started on Twilight.
And then Katniss came to us, as Gandalf once did, at the turn of the tide.
Katniss Everdeen is the protagonist of The Hunger Games trilogy written by Suzanne Collins. Like Buffy, Katniss was called to something greater and more sinister than she deserved. And like Buffy this calling represents for Katniss an, at times, insurmountable amount of sacrifice and servitude.
I don't want to give too many spoilers for the trilogy because it's my hope that Buffyphiles the world over will read it. What I will say is that Suzanne Collins has managed to do what Joss Whedon did in the late nineties. She has presented a heroine who's legacy and heroism is both inspiring and tragic. A heroine who's life is full of love and fulfillment but not without great hurt and loss.
The nuance of Buffy Summers is that she is a hero but does not take delight in the trappings of her heroics. There is no stylized glamour to the violence and depravity that Buffy must confront in her role as the Slayer. Nor does Katniss take joy in the callings of being the Mockingjay. Each ascends to the role because they know that not to do so could mean the harm of those they love. And while this sounds in print a whole like martyrdom the reality is that both Buffy and Katniss are resentful of their respective callings. This doesn't negate their willingness to bear their respective mantles but it does make them more relatable.
I'm not saying I won't force my future female offspring to be Buffy for Halloween every year.
But if she wanted to dress up as Katniss I wouldn't mind.
